Business

Unoccupied premises clauses: when an empty site loses cover

Many business property policies restrict cover once a building has sat empty for a set number of days. Here is how the clause reads, and what to do before the clock runs out.

By Vantage TeamPublished by Raphael Hermiz, Director, Qualified Insurance Broker7 min read

A tenant hands back the keys at the end of June. The landlord lists the shopfront, a few inspections come and go, and by early September nobody has been inside for weeks. Then a burst pipe floods the floor, or someone forces the back door. Whether the policy responds may now depend less on the damage than on the calendar, because many business property policies carry a condition about buildings left unoccupied.

What does an unoccupied premises clause actually do?

It suspends or restricts property cover once a building has been empty for a continuous period set out in the policy, unless the insurer has agreed in writing to keep insuring it. The reasoning on the insurer's side is that an empty building is a different risk: a leak runs for days before anyone sees it, a break-in goes unnoticed, and nobody is there to smell smoke.

In the wordings reviewed here, the clause appears in more than one place. Once as a general policy condition that obliges you to keep the building occupied or tell the insurer, and again as an exclusion or limitation inside individual sections of a business insurance package, such as glass. Reading only one of them gives an incomplete picture. The AAMI general condition, for example, applies across the policy except management liability, tax probe and goods in transit.

How long can a business building sit empty?

There is no single number. The period is whatever the wording says, and wordings from the same insurer group can differ. Two published examples make the point.

The AAMI Business Insurance PDS, prepared on 26 March 2024, says the insured is not covered while a building is unoccupied for a period of 60 days or more, unless AAMI agrees to insure it. A Vero business insurance PDS sets the same kind of condition at 90 days. Both are issued by AAI Limited, which shows how much the detail varies even within one insurer.

Two features of the wording matter more than the headline number. The period is continuous, so a building that sits empty for 50 days, is occupied for a weekend, and then sits empty again may or may not have reset the clock depending on how occupation is defined. And the condition is written as an obligation that runs from the first day, not just a cut-off at the end: the AAMI wording asks the insured to notify the insurer as soon as possible if a building will or is likely to be unoccupied for that long.

What counts as occupied?

Leaving stock, furniture or equipment inside usually does not make a building occupied. The Vero wording defines unoccupied as left vacant by the insured or any other authorised person whether furniture or other contents remain or not, and says that to have been occupied, the premises must have been used for business purposes for at least two consecutive days.

That definition rules out some common assumptions. A weekly visit to collect mail, a cleaner who comes once a fortnight, or a storeroom full of fittings may not amount to business use. The AAMI wording uses the terms unoccupied and untenanted without a dedicated definition, which leaves the ordinary meaning to do the work. Where a policy does not define the term, ask the insurer or your broker how it will be read rather than relying on your own interpretation.

For building owners, both wordings also refer to a building being untenanted. A landlord whose tenant has left can be caught by the clause even though the owner never occupied the premises in the first place. Owners of residential investment property face a parallel issue under landlord insurance, where vacancy conditions can also apply.

What still applies once cover is suspended?

In the wordings reviewed here, very little. The AAMI condition says the insured is simply not insured while the building is unoccupied past the limit. The Vero exclusion keeps cover for lightning, earthquake and subterranean fire, and for impact by vehicles, animals, trees, aircraft and some falling objects, but otherwise provides no cover at the building after 90 consecutive days unoccupied. Fire, storm, water damage, theft and malicious damage are not in that list.

Some benefits are built specifically for vacant space and still carry their own limit. The AAMI wording includes an additional benefit for glass breakage in a rentable area that is vacant and not leased, but excludes it once the premises has stayed unoccupied or untenanted for longer than 60 days without written agreement. A benefit designed for an empty tenancy is therefore still subject to the same clock.

Separate exclusions can apply regardless of the count of days. The Vero wording excludes damage to a building that is vacant awaiting or undergoing demolition, unless the insurer has agreed otherwise. A site being cleared for redevelopment can sit outside cover from the start.

Where does section 54 of the Insurance Contracts Act fit?

Section 54 can limit an insurer's ability to refuse a claim because of something the insured did or failed to do after the policy started, but it does not switch the unoccupancy clause off. Under section 54 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984, an insurer generally cannot refuse a claim by reason only of such an act and may instead reduce what it pays to reflect the prejudice it suffered. The section expressly extends act to an omission, including one that allows the state or condition of the insured property to alter.

The protection has a significant limit. Where the act or omission could reasonably be regarded as capable of causing or contributing to the loss, subsection (2) allows the insurer to refuse the claim, subject to the insured proving that no part, or only some part, of the loss was caused by it. An empty building and a theft, a fire or an undetected leak can be closely connected, so the insurer may argue that subsection (2) applies. How a particular claim falls depends on its facts, and it is not something to plan around. Treat the clause as binding and deal with it before the deadline.

When do businesses get caught by it?

The situations that bring the clause into play are mostly ordinary business events that happen to run past the deadline:

  • Between leases: a commercial landlord waiting on a new tenant.
  • Renovation or refit: a tenant has moved out while the fit-out is redone, or a new tenant has the keys but has not started trading.
  • Seasonal trading: a kiosk, holiday-town shop or agricultural shed that closes for part of the year.
  • Sale or relocation: the business has moved to new premises but the old site is not yet sold or handed back.
  • After a loss: a building damaged in one event and then left empty while repairs are scoped and approved.
  • Ill health or a pause in trading: an owner-operator who stops trading for a period without closing the business.

In each case the risk to the building changes on the day it empties, while the policy carries on unchanged until someone tells the insurer.

What to do when a site is going to be empty

Tell the insurer early and get the outcome in writing. Both wordings above allow the insurer to agree to keep insuring an unoccupied building, and both note that it may charge an additional premium, apply different conditions or impose a higher excess when it does. That agreement has to exist before the period runs out to be any use.

  • Note the date the building became unoccupied and count forward to the policy's limit. Put that date in the diary well ahead of the deadline.
  • Read both places the clause appears: the general condition and the exclusion in each property section, including glass and theft.
  • Notify the insurer, or your broker, as soon as an extended vacancy is likely, not when it is already over the limit.
  • Ask what conditions will apply. An insurer may ask for regular inspections, isolating water and gas, removing combustible waste, and keeping alarms monitored.
  • Keep a log of inspections with dates and photographs. If the policy asks for them, that record is what shows the condition was met.
  • Check whether a tenant's departure changes other parts of the cover, such as the sum insured for contents, signage and glass, and any interested party noted on the policy.
  • Tell the insurer again when the building is occupied, so the record of when the vacancy ended is clear.

For a retail shop or a cafe or restaurant between operators, it is worth reading the glass, theft and malicious damage sections alongside the general condition, since a shopfront has large areas of glass facing the street and the glass cover in both wordings above carries its own vacancy limit.

What Vantage checks before a site goes quiet

When a client tells Vantage a building is about to sit empty, the first thing the brokerage checks is the exact wording on the current policy: the number of days, how occupied is defined, which sections the condition applies to, and what, if anything, stays covered after the limit. Those details differ between insurers, as the two wordings above show, and the answer for one site does not carry over to another.

From there the job is to put the vacancy to the insurer before the deadline, set out the security and inspection arrangements, and get the insurer's position confirmed in writing. Where the existing insurer will not continue cover, the option is to approach insurers that will consider vacant property, on terms that reflect the changed risk. Either way, the time to raise it is the week the keys come back, not the week something goes wrong.

Filed under

Business

All insights

A conversation over an article?

Bring the specifics — we'll bring the cover.

Every business is different. If something in this article raised a question about your own cover, the fastest way to answer it is a short call.