Business

What a commercial lease requires you to insure

A clause-by-clause checklist for the insurance section of a shop, office or warehouse lease, and where it meets your policy.

By Vantage TeamPublished by Raphael Hermiz, Director, Qualified Insurance Broker7 min read

Most commercial leases contain an insurance clause that tells the tenant which policies to hold, at what limits, in whose names, and how to prove it. It is rarely long, and it is often drafted by the landlord's lawyer with the landlord's interests in mind. The terms are usually negotiable before signing and very hard to change afterwards, so the time to read it is while the lease is still a draft.

This article walks through the clauses that appear most often, what each one asks of your insurance, and the questions worth putting to your insurer or broker before you agree to them. It does not cover the rest of the lease. For rent, term, make good and options, a lawyer who works in commercial leasing is the right person to review the document.

What does the insurance clause in a lease usually require?

A typical clause requires the tenant to hold public liability cover at a stated minimum limit, insure its own contents and fit-out, and often insure plate glass in the premises. It may also require the landlord's interest to be noted on the policy, ask for a certificate of currency each year, and restrict what the tenant can do that might affect the landlord's own building insurance.

Some leases go further and require business interruption cover, workers compensation as required by law, or insurance for specific plant the tenant installs. Each of these is a separate obligation, and missing one can be a breach of the lease even if no claim ever happens.

  • Public liability, at a named limit per occurrence
  • Contents, stock and tenant's fit-out, often at replacement value
  • Plate glass, either insured by the tenant or recharged by the landlord
  • The landlord noted as an interested party
  • A waiver of subrogation or a release in the landlord's favour
  • Evidence of cover on request or at each renewal
  • A restriction on anything that could void or increase the landlord's building cover

How much public liability does a lease ask for?

The lease names the figure, usually as an amount such as $10 million or $20 million, and that figure is the one that matters, not a general rule of thumb. Read the wording closely: some clauses ask for a limit "per occurrence", some "in the aggregate", and some for a figure "or such higher amount as the landlord reasonably requires", which lets the landlord raise it during the term.

Also check what the cover must respond to. A clause that requires liability cover "for the premises" is different from one that requires cover for products sold from them. A cafe or retailer selling goods will usually want products liability alongside public liability, and the public liability page sets out how the two sections differ. When Vantage looks at a lease insurance clause, the limit is checked against the current policy schedule, because a renewal at the old limit after a new lease is signed is an easy mistake to make.

Who insures the glass?

Leases usually handle this one of two ways: the tenant insures the glass in the premises, or the landlord insures it and passes the cost on through outgoings. The clause will say which, and it is worth knowing before you arrange your own cover so you neither double up nor leave a gap.

Where the tenant must insure it, glass is often available as an optional section of a business package rather than as a standalone policy. Check whether the lease obliges you to cover all glass in the premises, including internal glass and shopfront signage, or only external glazing. Check too whether it requires temporary boarding up and replacement of lettering, which some policies cover and others limit.

What does noting the landlord's interest actually do?

Noting the landlord's interest records the landlord on your policy as a party with an interest in the insured property or liability. It is a common lease requirement. What it does not do, by default, is make the landlord a full insured with the same rights as you.

Leases use different words for this, such as "noted", "named as an interested party" or "named as a joint insured", and they are not interchangeable. An insurer may accept a noting and decline to name a landlord as a joint insured. If the lease wording asks for something your insurer will not do, raise it before signing so the clause can be amended, rather than discovering it when the landlord asks for a certificate showing it.

Why does a waiver of subrogation matter?

A waiver of subrogation is a promise that you, and therefore your insurer, will not pursue the landlord to recover a loss your policy has paid. Subrogation is the insurer's right to step into your shoes after a claim and recover from whoever caused it. If the lease takes that right away before the insurer has agreed, the insurer's position has been prejudiced, and your policy may treat that as a breach.

Many commercial policies allow you to waive rights against certain parties if you do so in writing before the loss, but the scope varies between wordings. A policy may permit a waiver in favour of some parties and not others, or require the insurer to be told, so check the wording rather than assuming. Leases also run the other way: a tenant may ask the landlord's building insurer to waive subrogation against the tenant, which protects you if your fit-out works or a kitchen fire damages the building. It is reasonable to ask for that mutual position during negotiation.

Can an indemnity clause outrun your policy?

Yes, and this is the clause most likely to create an uninsured exposure. Most leases include an indemnity from the tenant to the landlord for loss arising from the tenant's use of the premises. Some are drafted broadly enough to cover loss the tenant did not cause, such as an injury in a common area or damage arising from the building itself.

Public liability policies commonly exclude liability assumed under a contract, except to the extent you would have been liable anyway. An indemnity that goes beyond your legal liability may therefore sit outside the cover. The practical step is to send the indemnity and release clauses to your insurer or broker with the draft lease and ask a direct question: does the policy respond to this as written? If the answer is no, that is a point to raise with your lawyer while the lease can still be negotiated.

How do state retail leasing laws change the picture?

If the premises are a retail shop, state retail leasing legislation may limit what the landlord can pass on and require certain disclosures before you sign. Each state and territory has its own retail leasing law and its own dispute body, so the rules differ depending on where the shop is.

In Queensland, the Queensland Small Business Commissioner's outgoings fact sheet notes that under a retail shop lease the lessor cannot charge the tenant for excess payments under the lessor's insurance policy, and that a retail tenant is only liable for outgoings the lease specifies. In Victoria, the Victorian Small Business Commission's retail leases brochure for tenants says the landlord must provide a disclosure statement and the proposed lease at least 14 days before the lease is entered into, and that the disclosure statement sets out the outgoings the landlord can pass on. The landlord's insurance costs can be one of them, so the disclosure statement is where to see what you will be paying towards.

Leases of offices, warehouses and industrial units often fall outside retail leasing legislation, depending on how the relevant state defines a retail lease, which leaves more to the drafting. That makes the insurance clause in a non-retail lease worth reading even more carefully. For shopfronts, the retail insurance page covers the policy sections a retail tenant typically arranges.

A checklist to take to the lease review

Before signing, it helps to read the insurance clause with your current policy schedule beside it and work through a short list. The items below are the ones that most often turn up a mismatch.

  • The public liability limit, whether it is per occurrence or aggregate, and whether the landlord can raise it
  • Whether products liability is required as well as public liability
  • Who insures the glass, and whether internal glass and signage are included
  • The exact wording for the landlord's interest: noted, interested party or joint insured
  • Any waiver of subrogation or release, and whether your policy permits it
  • The scope of the tenant's indemnity, and whether it extends beyond your own negligence
  • Whether business interruption cover is required, and for how long
  • How often a certificate of currency must be supplied, and to whom
  • Any restriction on activities that could affect the landlord's building insurance, such as cooking, hot work or storing flammable goods
  • For a retail shop, the outgoings in the disclosure statement, including any insurance recharge

Anything on that list that your current cover does not meet is a question for the insurer and, if it cannot be met, a point to negotiate on the lease. The insurance clause and the policy should end up saying the same thing. A lawyer reviewing the lease and a broker reviewing the cover can each see half of the problem, so it is worth making sure both have read the clause.

Filed under

Business

All insights

A conversation over an article?

Bring the specifics — we'll bring the cover.

Every business is different. If something in this article raised a question about your own cover, the fastest way to answer it is a short call.