Business

Who can drive: driver restrictions on business vehicles

A commercial motor policy covers the vehicle, but the wording decides which drivers it will pay for, and at what cost.

By Vantage TeamPublished by Raphael Hermiz, Director, Qualified Insurance Broker7 min read

A business ute gets borrowed on a Saturday. An apprentice drives it to a job on Monday. A labourer who started last week moves it across the yard. Each of those trips raises the same question on a claim: was the person driving someone the policy agreed to cover, and on what terms. The commercial motor wordings reviewed for this article answer it in three places: the definition of an authorised driver, an extra excess for young or inexperienced drivers, and a general exclusion for drivers who are unlicensed or impaired.

Who counts as an authorised driver

On the wordings reviewed for this article, an authorised driver is anyone driving or using the vehicle with your consent. Both AAMI's Commercial Motor PDS and Vero's Motor Fleet PDS define the term in almost identical language: a person controlling, driving or using your vehicle with your consent.

That is broader than many owners expect. These policies do not require every driver to be named in advance. The trade-off is that consent becomes the hinge. "You" in a commercial policy means the insured business, so the question on a claim is whether the business consented, not whether some individual handed over the keys.

Not every policy works this way. Some are rated on a schedule of nominated drivers, and the commercial motor and fleet page explains how a driver schedule fits into a fleet program. Your own schedule and PDS are the only reliable guide to which model you have.

The age and inexperienced driver excess

Both wordings add a second excess when the driver at the time of the event was under 25 or new to that class of vehicle. It sits on top of the basic excess rather than replacing it.

AAMI's wording is a useful example because it sets the amounts out in full. For a car, 4WD, ute or van of not more than two tonnes carrying capacity, it lists an extra $500 for drivers under 21, $300 for drivers 21 or older but under 25, and $250 for inexperienced drivers. For a prime mover the extra excess climbs into the thousands and scales with the vehicle's insured amount and the number of trailers being towed. AAMI also states that this excess does not apply to glass, damage while parked, fire, malicious damage, theft or storm claims. Those figures are from that one PDS. Your own policy schedule will show the amounts that apply to you.

"Inexperienced" has a precise meaning. In both wordings it is a person 25 or over who has not held a licence for the class of vehicle being driven for the past two consecutive years. A 40-year-old who upgraded to a medium rigid licence last year can be an inexperienced driver of the truck while being an experienced driver of the ute.

For more on how this sits alongside standard, imposed and time excesses, see our guide to insurance excess types.

When a driver is unlicensed, impaired or outside licence conditions

An unlicensed or impaired driver usually takes the claim outside cover altogether, not just into a higher excess. Both PDSs exclude events where the driver was under the influence of alcohol, drugs or medication, was over the legal limit, refused a test, or was not licensed, not correctly licensed, or not complying with the conditions of their licence.

The last limb catches more people than the first three. A learner driving without a supervisor, a provisional driver breaching a passenger or vehicle restriction, or a car licence holder driving a vehicle that needs a light rigid licence can all fall within "not complying with the conditions of their licence" or "not correctly licensed".

Both wordings carry an important exception. The insurer will still cover the business if the owner was not the driver and can satisfy the insurer that they did not know, and could not reasonably have known, about the problem. AAMI extends that to directors and shareholders holding more than 15 per cent. The same clauses then allow the insurer to recover what it paid from the person who was driving, unless the law prevents it. So the business may be protected while the driver is left personally exposed.

What happens when an employee lends the ute to a friend

The outcome turns on consent, the friend's age and licence, and what the business could reasonably have known. Take a typical scenario: a tradesperson has a company ute on take-home use and lends it to a friend for a weekend, and the friend has an accident.

  • If the business allows staff to let others drive, or has done nothing to stop it, the friend may well be an authorised driver. The claim then proceeds like any other, with the age or inexperienced driver excess added if the friend is under 25 or newly licensed for that class.
  • If the friend was unlicensed, disqualified or over the limit, the general exclusion is engaged. Whether the business is still covered depends on whether it can show it did not know and could not reasonably have known. Even if it can, the insurer may pursue the friend for the cost.
  • If the business had a clear rule that company vehicles are not to be lent, and the employee broke it, there is a real question about whether the friend was driving with the business's consent at all. That question is decided on the wording and the facts, and it is exactly where a claim slows down.
  • Damage to someone else's property is handled under the policy's legal liability section, which on both wordings extends to authorised drivers. If the friend was not an authorised driver, that extension may not reach them.

None of this is unusual for a tradie business where utes go home with staff. A short written vehicle use policy that says who may drive, and that the vehicle is not to be lent, makes the consent question much easier to answer on both sides.

What you have to tell the insurer about drivers

Driver history is part of what the insurer asks about before cover starts and at renewal, and some policies also require you to tell them during the year. AAMI's PDS, for example, asks whether any authorised driver, including you, has had a licence endorsed, suspended or cancelled in the past five years, been charged with or convicted of certain criminal offences, or been charged with or convicted of a motor offence other than a parking fine.

The practical difficulty is that "any authorised driver" can include people the owner rarely thinks about: a casual who occasionally drives, a family member, a new starter. If the business does not know a driver's history, it cannot pass it on. Asking new drivers about licence status and recent offences when they start, and again before renewal, is a simple way to keep the answers accurate.

If something was not disclosed or a policy condition was breached, the insurer's response is not always a flat refusal. Section 54 of the Insurance Contracts Act limits when an insurer can refuse a claim because of something that happened after the contract was made. How it applies to a particular driver exclusion depends on the facts, and it is not a reason to skip the disclosure.

Fleets, heavy vehicles and named drivers

A fleet's claims history is part of what an insurer looks at when it rates the renewal, so driver controls matter beyond any single claim. A run of young-driver incidents can show up at renewal even if each claim was paid.

Heavy vehicles carry the sharpest numbers. On the AAMI and Vero wordings the age or inexperienced driver excess for a prime mover runs from $2,500 to $37,500, depending on the insured amount and whether more than one trailer was attached. For an operator considering a younger driver on a prime mover, that is worth knowing before they start, not after an incident. Our truck and owner driver page covers how those policies are usually structured, and the article on fleet policies versus individual policies explains where the rating approach changes.

Checks worth making before the next renewal

The checks below target the gap between how the vehicles are actually used and what the policy assumes. When Vantage reviews a commercial motor schedule, the driver questions are among the first we check against how the business really runs:

  • Does the policy cover anyone driving with consent, or only nominated drivers? If nominated, is the list current?
  • What are the age and inexperienced driver excesses on each vehicle type, and does anyone under 25 or newly licensed for a class drive regularly?
  • Do the licence classes of everyone who drives match the vehicles they drive, including trucks and towing combinations?
  • Is there a written rule on private use and lending company vehicles, and do staff know it?
  • Has every driver's licence status and recent motor offence history been collected, so the renewal answers are accurate?

Consider whether the policy's driver terms suit the way your vehicles are used, and raise any gap with your insurer or broker before it becomes a claim question.

Filed under

Business

All insights

A conversation over an article?

Bring the specifics — we'll bring the cover.

Every business is different. If something in this article raised a question about your own cover, the fastest way to answer it is a short call.