An Australian business sells a few hundred units of a product to customers in California, a customer is hurt, and a lawyer files suit in a Los Angeles court. Whether the business's liability policy responds depends on two short definitions that most people never read: the territorial limits and the jurisdiction clause. This article explains what each one does, why the United States and Canada are usually treated differently, and what changes for online sellers, consultants with overseas clients and tradespeople who work across state borders.
What is a territorial limit in a liability policy?
A territorial limit sets where the injury or damage has to happen for the policy to respond. The insuring clause of a typical public liability policy pays for personal injury or property damage that happens during the period of insurance, within the territorial limits, in connection with your business. If the event happens outside those limits, the insuring clause is never triggered, and none of the rest of the policy matters.
A jurisdiction clause answers a different question: where a claim can be brought, or a judgment enforced, and still be covered. The two often sit together, but they are not the same thing. A policy can cover an injury that happened in Sydney and still exclude the lawsuit if it is filed in a court in the United States. It can also cover an overseas event provided the claim is heard in an Australian court.
Why are the United States and Canada carved out?
Several published Australian liability wordings cover the rest of the world but treat the United States and Canada separately. The carve-out is not hidden. It usually sits in the definitions section, and the way it is drafted varies between insurers.
One example is an older broadform public and products liability wording hosted by BizCover. Its definition of territorial limits is anywhere in the world except the United States, Canada and their protectorates and territories. It then puts those countries back in for two specific situations: injury or damage arising from products exported there, and business visits by directors, officers or employees who are not resident there, other than where those people perform manual work.
A different approach appears in the Victorian Managed Insurance Authority's combined liability wording. Its territory is worldwide, but a separate exclusion removes claims made or commenced in a court or tribunal in the United States or Canada, and claims arising from the enforcement of a judgment from an action brought there. That last part matters: winning a case at home does not help if the claimant takes a North American judgment and seeks to enforce it.
What happens to defence costs in a US or Canadian claim?
Defence costs can be counted inside the limit of liability for a North American claim, rather than paid on top of it. Both wordings above say so in terms. The broadform wording provides that for a claim in a court in the United States, Canada or their territories, the total payable including defence costs and supplementary payments will not exceed the limit of liability. The VMIA wording makes the limit inclusive of defence costs for claims in those courts.
In practice this means a policy with a headline limit of $20 million has less available for damages once lawyers have been paid, and a long defence erodes the cover before any settlement is reached. If you sell into North America, the limit that matters is the one left after defence, not the one printed on the schedule. Our article on $10 million versus $20 million public liability covers how limits are set more generally.
What should online sellers check before shipping overseas?
Online sellers should check whether exports to the United States and Canada are inside the territorial limits, and whether that depends on having declared them. Some wordings, like the broadform example, include products exported to North America by definition. Others treat North American sales as an extension that has to be requested and rated, and an insurer that has not been told about those sales may take the view that it never agreed to cover them.
Points worth raising with your broker or insurer:
- Whether products sold through an overseas marketplace are treated as exported by you, or as sold by the platform.
- Your actual turnover into the United States and Canada, declared rather than estimated after a claim.
- Whether the jurisdiction clause excludes claims brought in North American courts even where the products cover applies.
- Whether defence costs for those claims sit inside or outside the limit.
- Whether a marketplace or distributor requires a certificate naming them, and in which country.
Our separate guide to product liability for online sellers covers the domestic side.
Does a consultant with overseas clients face the same issue?
A consultant faces the same question, but usually under a professional indemnity policy rather than public liability. Advice delivered by video call from Brisbane to a client in Toronto can lead to a claim in Canada, and a professional indemnity wording will have its own territorial and jurisdiction terms that may not match the liability policy. The difference between public liability and professional indemnity matters here because the two policies are drafted separately and can carve out North America in different ways.
The client contract is part of the picture. A governing law and jurisdiction clause that sends disputes to an Australian court sits more comfortably with a policy that excludes North American proceedings than one that nominates a court in New York. That is a contract question for your lawyer, but it is worth knowing about before you sign, because an insurer is likely to read the contract when a claim arrives.
What changes for tradespeople working interstate?
For most tradespeople, working interstate does not raise a territorial limits problem on the liability policy, because a definition covering everywhere except North America already includes every Australian state and territory. The issues that do come up sit elsewhere in the program.
- Workers compensation is state and territory based. Each scheme has cross-border rules for workers who travel, and an employer sending staff interstate for an extended job should confirm with its scheme insurer which state the workers are connected to.
- Tools and portable equipment cover may have its own territorial limit, which need not match the liability section, so it is worth reading that section separately.
- A principal contractor in another state may require different limits or interested party wording, and will check the certificate of currency before you start.
- Trade licences are issued by the states, and an insurer may ask whether you hold the licence required where the work is done.
Tradespeople who travel overseas for work need to look at the business visits carve-back in particular. In the broadform example, business visits to North America are covered only where the employee does not perform manual work. A trip to sign a contract may sit inside the definition. A trip to install equipment for a customer in Vancouver may not. Our tradie insurance page sets out the other covers a trade business usually carries.
What Vantage checks when a business trades across borders
When Vantage reviews a liability program for a business with interstate or overseas activity, the first step is to read the territorial limits definition and the jurisdiction clause together, then compare them against how the business actually earns its revenue. A business package may combine liability with property and other sections, and each section can carry its own territory, so we read each one rather than relying on the first.
The useful questions are concrete: which countries your customers are in, whether staff travel and what they do when they arrive, which courts your contracts nominate, and whether the insurer has been told all of this in writing. Whether any extension is appropriate depends on your circumstances. What does not change is that the definitions decide the outcome, and they are easier to fix before the first overseas order than after the first overseas claim.
Filed under
Business
